REPORT. THE CIIC 2003 ANNUAL MEETING


According to what had been announced, the CIIC held its annual meeting on October 29 and 30 (Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe).

1. Participants:

1.       Officers:

  1. María Rosa Suárez-Inclán (Spain), President
  2. Dosso Sindou (Ivory Coast), Vice-president for Africa
  3. Guy Masson (Canada), Vice-president for America
  4. Rosa Anna Genovese (Italy), Secretary General
  5. Aimé Gonçalves (Benin) Assistant Vice-president for Africa
  6. Mohaman Haman (Cameroon), Assistant Vice-president for Africa
  7. Edward Matenga (Zimbabwe), Assistant Vice-president for Africa
  8. Tamara Blanes (Cuba), Assistant Vice-president for America
  9. Carlos Mesén (Costa Rica), Assistant Vice-president for America
  10. María Teresa Gaona (Paraguay), Assistant Vice-president for America
  11. Kunie Sugio (Japan), Assistant Vice-president for Asia-Pacific
  12. Todor Krestev (Bulgaria), Assistant to the Secretary General

 

  1. Other members present
  1. Edwin Binda (Chile), Voting member
  2. Cecilia Calderón (Mexico), Associate member
  3. Ana María Crespi (Uruguay), Voting member
  4. Rocío Cutipé (Peru) , Associate member
  5. Carmen Daly (Venezuela), Associate member
  6. Viera Dvorakova (Slovakia), Voting member
  7. Colin Fortune (South Africa), Voting member
  8. Rubén García Miranda (Uruguay), Associate member
  9. Lidia Klupsz (Poland), Voting member
  10. David Mallia (Malta), Voting member
  11. Alberto Martorell (Peru), Associate member
  12. Mario Molina (Nicaragua), Voting member
  13. Carlos Pernaut (Argentina), Voting member
  14. Susana Sampaio (Brazil), Voting member

 

  1. Guest (observers):
  1. Eman Assi (Palestine)
  2. Adriana A.C. de Castro (Brazil)
  3. Betina Adams (Brazil)
  4. Poonam Chaudhary (India)
  5. Joseph Eboreime (Nigeria)
  6. José María García de Miguel (Spain)
  7. Laura Peñarroya (Spain)
  8. Carmen Pérez (Spain)
  9. Angela Rojas (Cuba)
  10. María Claudia Romero (Colombia)
  11. Ruth Shady (Peru)
  12. Ileana Vásquez (Venezuela)
  13. Olabiyi Yai (Benin)

 

Members excused:

  1. Samitha Manawadu (Sri Lanka), Vice-president for Asia-Pacific
  2. Sandy Blair (Australia), Assistant Vice-president for Asia-Pacific
  3. Stuart Smith (United Kingdom), Voting member
  4. Jean-Louis Luxen (Belgium), Voting member
  5. Ron van Oers (The Netherlands), Voting member

 

 

2. CIIC information and reports  

It is reminded that the CIIC members are kept regularly informed on its activities by means of circular letters, reports and the documentation included on its website. This year the CIIC has elaborated three reports. Two of them were distributed in February and in May this year. Following the request made by the present Vice-president in charge of the ISC’s of ICOMOS, a third report was prepared according to his instructions in view of the meeting of presidents of ISC’s  held in Victoria Falls on October 27 this year (see attachment n.1).

 

3. The CIIC website and publications.

The CIIC website includes different sections (1. Statutes, 2. Elections and Committee’s Officers, 3. Members, 4. Background, 5. Activities,  6. News, 7. Documents, 8. Inventory Records,  9. Library, 10. Links and 11. Contacts). All the conclusions of the scientific meetings held by the CIIC can be consulted on section 6. The last book published by the CIIC with the proceedings of previous conferences and seminars (mainly that held in Pamplona in 2001) has been entirely included on the section devoted to “Library”. This section is open to other publications and a new section can be devoted to scientific contributions from our members.

 

4. Steps towards a general understanding of the conceptual and substantive aspects of Cultural Routes.

Following the recommendation presented by the CIIC to the 13th General Assembly, a Task Force composed by the President and the Vice-Presidents of the CIIC met at the end of May in Madrid. They were also accompanied by a short group of experts on cultural routes that represented on equitable basis the different regions of the world. The selection of these experts was made taking into account their past contribution to the development of conceptual and doctrinal aspects referred to this specific category of cultural heritage. As it was announced in the second report sent to all the CIIC members this year, the aim of this workshop was to precise the formal definition of cultural routes and other related aspects for general understanding. The conclusions, which follow entirely those elaborated by the CIIC in its scientific seminars, can be seen at the CIIC website under the title “News” and were presented at this meeting in Zimbabwe. It was also announced that they are been considered in order to enrich the text of the WH Convention’s guidelines which is under revision.  

5. Preliminary ideas for the elaboration of a Charter on Cultural Routes.

According to the CIIC programme guidelines for the present triennium, the CIIC should elaborate a draft of a Charter on Cultural Routes. This draft should presumably be ready so as to be circulated in 2004. It was therefore agreed the establishment of a Task Force who should work on this field. Those who have made especially important contributions to the development of conceptual and doctrinal aspects during the past years shall necessarily integrate this group. Also, in order to ensure the participation of experts from all the continents and to keep the number of them within reasonable limits- so that their task is really efficient – the following members shall integrate this specific Task Force: President: María Rosa Suárez-Inclán; General Coordinators: Guy Masson and Francisco Javier López  Morales; AFRICA: Abderrahman Chorfi; Dosso Sindou; Edward Matenga; AMERICA. Tamara Blanes; Alberto Martorell; Carlos Pernaut; EUROPE: Sofia Avgerinou-Kolonias; Todor Krestev; Ron van Oers; ASIA-PACIFIC: Kunie Sugio; Samitha Manawadu; Sandy Blair. Even though it does not seem reasonable to surpass the limit of 12 members, any member wishing to participate on this effort is cordially invited to propose his/her candidature. In any case, the CIIC Board of Directors shall take the definitive decision on this item. Independently of that, all the CIIC members have been invited to re-read the doctrinal documents elaborated by the CIIC (all of them are available in our website) and to send their suggestions for the draft of this Charter. A first approach to this question was presented and discussed at Victoria Falls (see attachment n. 2), and once the first draft is ready it shall be submitted to consideration of all the CIIC members.

 

6. Research Centres on Cultural Routes

It was announced the creation of a high level research centre at the Polytechnic University of Madrid. Steps have also been undertaken for the establishment of a centre devoted to fortifications related to cultural routes in Peñíscola (Castellón).

 

7. CIIC meetings in 2004

Following the call made to all members last February for hosting the meetings of the CIIC in the present triennium, several suggestions were received. Focusing in 2004, the suggestion made by Cecilia Calderon, from Mexico, seemed to be the one offering more possibilities. As expected, she informed on the progress already made and it was agreed to hold a meeting in Chihuahua in spring 2004. Another meeting will probably take place in Peñíscola.

 

8. Member’s activities

All members had been requested to describe their activities in the field of cultural routes during the present year. Not many of them have sent a report, though there is quite a considerable number of experts that have worked hard on filling the CIIC inventory records related to different cultural routes.

The President reminds that all the CIIC members are expected to be active on carrying out some activities in their country and doing some research work in accordance with the programme approved for the present triennium. This specially means preparing the pre-inventory of cultural routes in their region, by filling the specific inventory records that, in accordance with the agreements taken in previous meetings, have been elaborated by our colleagues and published on the CIIC website (www.icomos-ciic-org).

It is agreed that the CIIC Vice-presidents and their assistants shall help to identify and promote at least a main cultural route per continent and fill the “identification” and “promotion” forms, as well as the appropriate specific ones, all of which can be found in the CIIC website. There are some areas where important projects have been undertaken, like the “Camino Real Intercontinental”-the intercontinental royal path-between Europe and America which also extends its way up to Asia, the “Quebrada de Humahuaca” (this is but a small part of the former one and also of the “Inca’s path”, both of which have other really outstanding parts that deserve to be identified and promoted as a priority), besides other projects. In Europe there is the “Camino de Santiago”- the Saint Jacques Route- and research work has also been carried out in Malta (pilgrim’s routes and fortifications), Greece, other countries in East Southern Europe, etc. Yet, some important routes for the historic development of Europe like the Roman ones are still ignored. With respect to Africa and Asia, independently of the work done on the field of fortifications which was presented to the CIIC congress held in Ibiza in 1999, and other interesting contributions also presented to the CIIC scientific meetings by its members, there is not a main project which is being developed by using the above referred inventory records. There are outstanding cultural routes in both Asia and Africa that deserve to be studied by the CIIC experts. This aim is very important taken into account that cultural routes shall be one of the two topics of the 15th  General Assembly of ICOMOS in China.

It is also agreed that membership shall be submitted to revision next year so that  those  who do not make any contribution to the CIIC work shall loose their condition of member.

9. Membership

According to the CIIC Statutes, at the beginning of this year those voting members who were appointed for the last term (1999-2002) were required to confirm  their appointment for the present one (2003-2005 second term) and most of them were confirmed by their national committee. With respect to those members who had never attended a CIIC meeting (or not so for the last 3 years) without excusing their participation for due cause the CIIC asked directly their National Committee to nominate a new voting member if they wished to do so. Only three National Committees gave an answer so that two new voting members and one associate member were proposed. For the rest of them, as there was not a positive answer from their national committee, their names were deleted from the CIIC list of members. Other proposals for new members have been received during the present year and were taken into account at the annual meeting held in Victoria Falls, with the following result:

New members admitted:

             As voting members:

    1. Aysil Yavu (Turkey)
    2. Natalya Gyulnazaryan (Armenia)
    3. Linda María Roca (Dominican Rep.)
    4. Fernando Rosas (Peru)
    5. Michael Romero Taylor (USA)
    6. Lena Kim (Korea)
    7. Joseph Eboreime (Nigeria)
    8. Eman Assi (Palestine)
    9. Poonam Chaudhary (India

As associate members:

1.      Pedro de Manuel (Spain)

2.      Elena Ramos (Paraguay)

3.      Alfredo Conti (Argentina)

4.      Angela Rojas (Cuba)

5.      María Claudia Romero (Colombia)

6.      Simon Makuvaza (Zimbabwe)

7.      Ruth Shady (Peru)

8.      Ileana Vásquez (Venezuela)

9.      Olabiyi Yai (Benin)

 

 10. Member’s directory

As usual, the list of the CIIC members was updated in the first part of this year. All members are requested to communicate any change on their data. Mr. Marouani, from Mauritania, has finally sent his new email address, and Mr. Matenga, from Zimbabwe, is kindly asked to do the same.

11. Information on the RecorDim project

At the request of Guy Masson, the CIIC Vice-president for America, his Canadian colleague Robin Letellier, who is the international co-ordinator of the RecorDim initiative, was invited to make a short presentation of this project (see attachment n.3). 

12. Acknowledgment

In closing, the members expressed the Committee’s thanks to ICOMOS Zimbabwe for hosting the General Assembly and for their hospitality.  

There being no further business, the annual meeting of the committee was adjourned.

Victoria Falls. Zimbabwe

30 October 2003

María Rosa Suárez-Inclán

President of the ICOMOS CIIC

 

www.icomos-ciic.org